No Country for the Innocents
Analysis of the Release Plan for Detainees under El Salvador’s State of Exception
By Daniel Olmedolmedo
Introduction
At the press conferences of 13 and 16 October 2026, the President of El Salvador said that his government had a plan to release persons detained during the state of exception. The plan would only include sentence-reduction measures for convicted persons or for those who, even though their proceedings are still pending judgment, the government presumes to be guilty. The purpose of this report is to assess the available information on that plan and to propose public policy recommendations.
First, the context of the state of exception in force in El Salvador since March 2022 is presented (1). Next, the public information on a possible detainee release plan is set out (2). The following part describes the pathways that Salvadoran law offers to implement the general guidelines that President Bukele has announced for that plan: conditional release, early conditional release, controlled release, and the abbreviated procedure (3). The last part assesses the information provided about the plan and identifies the risks it poses for all those held in pretrial detention who have not yet been convicted. Finally, a solution is proposed based on the recommendations that GIPES made in due course (4).
We hope that this report will be a useful input for relevant actors with the capacity to influence the Salvadoran authorities. Salvadorans are primarily responsible for resolving the human rights crisis caused by the state of exception, but it will be very difficult for them to do so without the support of the international community.1. The State of Exception in El Salvador
Between 25 and 27 March 2022, the gangs, known as maras, committed 87 homicides in El Salvador. In response to that extraordinary situation, on the 27th the Legislative Assembly decreed a state of exception, through which it suspended certain fundamental rights.
Since its initial approval, the state of exception has been extended on 55 occasions. By its nature, it should be a temporary and extraordinary measure, yet it has remained in force for more than four years and six months. As of October 2026, at least 93.334 people have been detained under the state of exception.
In 2024, the International Group of Experts for the Investigation of Human Rights Violations in the Context of the State of Exception in El Salvador (hereinafter GIPES) was created. The group is supported by the Due Process of Law Foundation (DPLF), the International Commission of Jurists (ICJ), the International Federation for Human Rights (FIDH), InterJust, the IMPACTUM Research Project, and the Human Rights in Context Program at Ghent University (Belgium ).
On 11 March 2026, GIPES published the report El Salvador at a Crossroads: Crimes Against Humanity Under the Public Security Policy. The report concludes that there is a “reasonable basis” to affirm that, in accordance with the Rome Statute, crimes against humanity have been committed under the state of exception.
On 15 July 2026, Amnesty International (hereinafter AI) published the report “Seguridad sin derechos: El impacto de las detenciones arbitrarias masivas y la negación del debido proceso en la posible comisión de crímenes de lesa humanidad en El Salvador. That report also concluded that crimes against humanity may be occurring in El Salvador during the state of exception.
Both reports highlight that one of the acts that would be giving rise to these alleged crimes against humanity is the systematic and widespread imprisonment of people during the state of exception.
2. A Prisoner Release Plan in El Salvador?
Ibrajim Bukele is the brother of the President of El Salvador, Nayib Bukele. Three of the president’s brothers —among them Ibrajim— hold no public office, but operate as strategists and decisive actors in the design and execution of public policy.
On 3 April 2026, in a post from his X account, Ibrajim referred to the persons detained during the state of exception. The president’s brother said: “There is an independent team reviewing case by case.” He then stated that this team “works hand in hand with the Attorney General’s Office, the Ministry of Justice and Penitentiary Centers.” And he added: “Part of the team is also part of the First Lady’s office. Nobody wants innocent people in prison.”
On 13 October, at a press conference given by Nayib Bukele, a journalist asked him about the status of that commission for evaluating cases from the state of exception. Bukele said: “I don’t know exactly what [my brother] meant, but I imagine that what he meant, which is what we are doing, and I said it once publicly as well, is that we have no intention of having anyone who is not guilty in prison.” He then added: “We have a plan and I mentioned it the other time, I think it would benefit around 50% more or less of the inmates in El Salvador who have collaborated with gangs with an early release, that is, he is guilty, but releasing him conditionally, right? releasing him with monitoring, with conditional release.”
On 16 October, Bukele took part in a press conference with the President of Costa Rica. There, he gave new information about the prisoner release plan he had referred to three days earlier. He said: “What I said was that we are going to review approximately 50%; it could be 45%, it could be 55%, of the cases of those who were imprisoned for being gang collaborators, not gang members.”
The president said that there were 96.457 persons linked to gangs in El Salvador’s prisons. He classified them according to their degree of involvement with those criminal organizations, as follows:
Homeboys: 42.125.
Members no-brincados (non-initiated): 25.910.
Paros: 17.793.
Collaborators: 10.629.
Bukele said that only some of the inmates linked to gangs, those at the lowest level (collaborator), could obtain prison benefits “to be able to get out sooner.”
The president did not clarify whether the persons deprived of liberty to whom he referred are persons in pretrial detention whose judicial proceedings remain active, or persons who have already been convicted. There is no official data that make it possible to verify which group Mr. Bukele was referring to; one of the characteristics of the security and penitentiary policy is the lack of transparency and the systematic violation of the right of access to public information.
Beyond those statements at the press conferences of 13 and 16 October 2026, there is no clear information about the content and scope of the prisoner release plan to which the president referred.
In any case, the only benefit that has been communicated as part of that plan is the commutation of sentences. On that basis, if such a plan exists, it appears to be aimed only at convicted persons, or at persons the government presumes to be guilty even though no judgment has yet been issued. The next section addresses the pathways that, under Salvadoran law, the government could activate for the population it would seek to benefit.
3. Legal Pathways to Grant Benefits to the Guilty
3.1. Convicted Persons
3.1.1. Conditional Release
Conditional release is a benefit that may be granted to persons sentenced to prison terms in El Salvador. It allows a convicted person to replace the remainder of their prison sentence with a regime of liberty subject to certain conditions or rules of conduct. Granting this benefit is the responsibility of the Penitentiary Supervision and Sentence Enforcement Judge.
To obtain this benefit, the convicted person must meet the following requirements:
Have served two-thirds of the sentence imposed.
Obtain a favorable report from the Regional Criminological Council certifying good conduct.
Not display a high degree of aggressiveness or dangerousness.
Have fulfilled, or guarantee the fulfillment of, the civil obligations determined in the conviction, or demonstrate the impossibility of paying.
This benefit cannot be granted to persons convicted of simple homicide, aggravated homicide, femicide, aggravated femicide, rape, rape of a minor or incapacitated person, or aggravated rape, nor for offenses committed in the form of organized crime.
Conditional release may also be granted to persons who are incapacitated or suffer from an incurable illness in its terminal stage, who pose no social risk whatsoever, and who have been convicted of offenses that do not carry severe penalties or involve conduct of exceptional dangerousness.
The proceeding to grant this benefit may be initiated at the request of the convicted person or ex officio by the court.
3.1.2. Early Conditional Release
Early conditional release may be granted before the convicted person has served the two-thirds of the sentence that ordinary conditional release regularly requires. It is an exceptional measure.
It may be granted to those who have served half of the sentence and have carried out work, cultural, occupational or other activities that allow a favorable social reintegration to be predicted. It may also be granted to a convicted person over sixty years of age who has served one-third of the sentence imposed and suffers from chronic degenerative diseases or severe organic damage, as well as to those who are incapacitated or suffer from an incurable illness in its terminal stage, who pose no social risk whatsoever, and who have been convicted of offenses that do not carry severe penalties or involve conduct of exceptional dangerousness.
The competent authority to grant this benefit is the Penitentiary Supervision and Sentence Enforcement Judge. The Regional Criminological Councils may propose its granting to the court.
This measure likewise cannot be granted to persons convicted of simple homicide, aggravated homicide, femicide, aggravated femicide, rape, rape of a minor or incapacitated person, or aggravated rape, nor for offenses committed in the form of organized crime.
3.1.3. Controlled Release
In March 2026, El Salvador approved a constitutional reform that enabled life imprisonment. That same month, a reform to the Penal Code was approved that established life imprisonment as the sole and automatic penalty for the offenses of simple homicide, aggravated homicide, rape, rape of a minor or incapacitated person, aggravated rape and aggravated rape of a minor, and membership in a terrorist organization.
Controlled release is a benefit that may be granted to persons sentenced to life imprisonment. The beneficiary of this measure will be subject to control measures for a period of five years. The competent authority to grant this benefit is the criminal court.
A requirement to access this benefit is to have served the applicable review periods for life sentences. These are:
For offenses committed by minors: 25 years.
If convicted of a single offense: 30 years.
If convicted of multiple offenses: 35 years.
If a specific aggravating circumstance or qualified extreme gravity was determined: 40 years.
For the granting of this benefit to be considered, the convicted person must obtain from the Regional Criminological Council a favorable report on their penitentiary progress, participation in reintegration programs, psychological and psychiatric reports, and their prognosis of dangerousness and possibility of reintegration.
3.2. Persons Under Prosecution
The Salvadoran criminal justice system includes the abbreviated procedure as a benefit to which persons who have not yet been convicted may have access. It is a special way of ending criminal proceedings in which the accused admits the facts and agrees to be tried without a full oral trial, in exchange for a lesser penalty.
A fundamental element is that the accused confesses, judicially or extrajudicially, to having committed the offenses attributed to them. This confession may be used as evidence of the participation of other accused persons in the facts under investigation.
The main benefit that may be granted to the accused is that a penalty ranging from one-third of the minimum up to the minimum of the prison sentence provided for the charged offense is applied. If the Attorney General requests it, the penalty may be even lower.
In cases where a person is charged with offenses committed in the form of organized crime, the lowest threshold for reducing the penalty is half of the minimum of the prison sentence provided for the charged offense. And in exceptional cases it may be as low as one-quarter of the minimum, if so authorized by the Attorney General. Another benefit that may be granted is serving the sentence in a medium- or minimum-security prison.
4. What About the Innocents?
From Nayib Bukele’s statements, it follows that the prisoner release plan is aimed at benefiting persons who have been convicted, or whom the government presumes to be guilty even though no judgment has yet been issued and their proceedings remain active. What has been revealed so far indicates no intention to release:
Those who have been detained and prosecuted during the state of exception and against whom there is no evidence that they committed the offenses attributed to them.
Those who have already been convicted without sufficient evidence that they committed the offenses of which they were accused.
This section presents theoretical considerations on the presumption of innocence (4.1) and the prohibition of forced confessions (4.2), then analyzes the risks posed by the abbreviated procedure mechanism (4.3), and concludes with the measures that could be adopted to benefit innocent persons deprived of liberty during the state of exception (4.4).
4.1. Presumption of Innocence
The International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (hereinafter ICCPR) establishes that anyone charged with a criminal offense has the right to be presumed innocent until proven guilty according to law. In this regard, the Human Rights Committee has said that guilt cannot be presumed unless the charge has been proved beyond reasonable doubt, and that all public authorities must refrain from prejudging the outcome of a trial, for instance by abstaining from making public statements declaring the guilt of the accused.
The American Convention on Human Rights (hereinafter ACHR) also establishes that every person accused of a criminal offense has the right to be presumed innocent so long as their guilt has not been proven. The Inter-American Court of Human Rights has said that an indispensable requirement for a criminal conviction is the conclusive demonstration of guilt.
In El Salvador, the Constitution provides that every accused person shall be presumed innocent until their guilt is proven according to law and in a public trial, in which all the guarantees necessary for their defense are ensured. And the Criminal Procedure Code reaffirms that principle, stating that the burden of proof lies with the accusers.
The presumption of innocence has not been suspended in El Salvador during the state of exception.
4.2. Forced Confessions
Under the ICCPR, no one may be compelled to testify against themselves or to confess guilt. On that basis, the Human Rights Committee has said that the authorities must not exert direct or indirect physical or psychological pressure on an accused person in order to obtain a confession of guilt. Confessions obtained in that manner are invalid, and it is for the State to prove that the statements of the accused were made of their own free will.
The Convention against Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment establishes that one of the purposes of torture may be to obtain a confession or to punish a person for an act that they are suspected of having committed; and for that reason States may not admit such confessions as evidence. The Committee against Torture has determined that this prohibition also applies when the confession has been obtained through “ill-treatment,” and not exclusively through torture.
For its part, the ACHR provides that no one may be compelled to be a witness against themselves or to plead guilty. And it adds that a confession is valid only if it is made without coercion of any kind.
The Constitution of El Salvador also provides that persons may not be compelled to testify. This guarantee has been suspended during the state of exception.
4.3. Risks Posed by the Abbreviated Procedure
As explained in section 3.2, the abbreviated procedure is a tool that could be used in a plan to offer benefits to persons detained during the state of exception who have not yet been convicted. The systematic and widespread application of abbreviated procedures to this population would have the following effects:
The confessions of the accused would be massively incorporated as evidence of the commission of the offenses attributed to them.
The clearing of the numerous criminal proceedings opened during the state of exception would be expedited.
The government narrative that all those detained during the state of exception were guilty would be reinforced.
The accused would be sentenced to lower prison terms than those they would have received without an abbreviated procedure.
The abbreviated procedure is a valid tool in the Salvadoran criminal justice system. But for it to operate regularly, conditions must exist that guarantee that the confessions of the accused have been made without any coercion.
The Inter-American Commission on Human Rights has expressed its concern over reports of torture and ill-treatment of persons in the custody of the Salvadoran authorities. GIPES and Amnesty International have maintained that there are indications that, in a widespread and systematic manner, the Salvadoran prison system is the site of torture, enforced disappearances, forced nudity, lack of medical care, being forced to witness acts of aggression against other inmates, prolonged incommunicado detention, and denial of adequate medical care; and that such attacks could amount to crimes against humanity.
From an institutional standpoint, for conditions to exist that guarantee a confession free of any coercion, the Attorney General’s Office and the Judiciary must act independently. In this regard, in the latest edition of the Rule of Law Index, the sub-indicator “Government powers are effectively limited by the judiciary” gives El Salvador a score of 0.34/1.0 (rank 120 out of 143 countries assessed); and with regard to the independence of the Attorney General’s Office, the sub-indicator on whether “Government officials are sanctioned for misconduct” gives the country a score of 0.27/1.0 (rank 131 out of 143 countries).
In addition, as stated above, the state of exception has suspended, since March 2022, article 12 paragraph 2 of the Constitution. This includes the prohibition on compelling anyone to testify. This has occurred even though the ICCPR expressly establishes certain rights that cannot be suspended in a state of emergency, and the United Nations Human Rights Committee has recognized that this includes the prohibition on suspending judicial guarantees. Likewise, the Inter-American Court of Human Rights has affirmed that the principles of due process recognized in article 8 of the ACHR cannot be suspended during a state of emergency; among them, the right not to be compelled to testify against oneself.
Therefore, under no circumstances should the prohibition on compelling a person to testify have been suspended in El Salvador, yet that suspension remains in force after more than four years. And without that constitutional guarantee, the foundation that sustains the legitimacy of the abbreviated procedure is completely undermined: a confession by the accused that is free from coercion.
For all of the above, it cannot be considered that the Salvadoran criminal justice system provides conditions for the accused to confess the offenses attributed to them freely and without risk of coercion. As a result, the use of the abbreviated procedure for persons prosecuted during the state of exception can be instrumentalized as a means of convicting innocent people and entrenching human rights violations.
4.4. Pathways to a Solution for the Innocent
The situation of those detained during the state of exception is a matter of serious concern. The massive scale of the phenomenon of arbitrary detentions aggravates the problem.
It is necessary for these tens of thousands of cases to find a judicial resolution that guarantees punishment of those responsible for the offenses committed and promotes public security. But justice, truth, and the fundamental rights of the accused must also be weighed. This means that a solution cannot consist of closing all the proceedings through mass confessions and automatic convictions.
A balanced solution must include an individualized analysis of the case of each person detained during the state of exception, in order to objectively assess the evidence presented and, on that basis, define the judicial strategy to be followed. With tens of thousands of cases, it is impossible for the Salvadoran authorities to carry out this task on their own. In light of this, GIPES made a recommendation to the Salvadoran State: “Create an independent commission for the review of judicial cases, with international support, working alongside the justice system, to select and classify cases with a view to reaching legal and humanitarian outcomes.” Henceforth, the commission proposed by GIPES will be referred to as the Ad Hoc Commission.
The purpose of the Ad Hoc Commission should not be to replace the powers of the Attorney General’s Office or of the courts, but to act as an auxiliary body. For this to happen, it is necessary for the Salvadoran State, and in particular the Executive Branch and the Attorney General’s Office, to accept it and to be willing to cooperate with it in a coordinated manner.
The usefulness of the Ad Hoc Commission depends on its meeting certain minimum characteristics, in order to avoid the risk of legitimizing a process that does not correct arbitrary detentions but rather administers them.
Recommended characteristics of the Ad Hoc Commission
1 | Independence. Neither the appointment of the members of the Ad Hoc Commission nor its funding may depend on the Salvadoran State. |
2 | Universe of cases defined in advance. It must be established beforehand which cases the commission will examine. One temporal criterion may be persons detained since the start of the state of exception (27 March 2022). Another criterion may be based on the type of offense charged; for example, unlawful groups (art. 345 of the Penal Code) or membership in a terrorist organization known as a gang (art. 344-A). |
3 | Unrestricted access to information. The commission must have unrestricted access to the judicial case files and to those of the Attorney General’s Office related to each case. |
4 | Individualized analysis. The commission must examine each case individually. |
5 | Report assessing the evidence. The analysis of each case must conclude with a report that assesses the evidence presented in the proceedings and, on that basis, formulates a recommendation on the action the Attorney General’s Office should take. |
6 | Recommendations in cases without a conviction. If it is concluded that the charges cannot be substantiated and there is no reasonable possibility of introducing new evidence, the commission may recommend that the Attorney General’s Office request definitive dismissal, pursuant to article 350 of the Criminal Procedure Code. If it is considered that new evidence could be introduced in the future, it will recommend requesting provisional dismissal, pursuant to article 351 of the same code. |
7 | Recommendations in cases with a final conviction. If the person has already been convicted by a final judgment and it is concluded that the conviction was based on false evidence, that a constitutional guarantee was directly and manifestly violated, or that there are new facts or evidence, the commission will recommend that the Attorney General’s Office file a motion for review, pursuant to article 489 of the Criminal Procedure Code. |
8 | Limited disclosure. The reports issued by the commission will also be delivered to the defense counsel or relatives of the convicted person, so that they may file any appeals or legal actions they consider appropriate on their own. |
8 | Standing to file habeas corpus. The commission may directly file habeas corpus petitions before the second-instance chambers or before the Constitutional Chamber of the Supreme Court of Justice. |
Source: Author’s own elaboration
5. Conclusions
El Salvador has been under a state of exception since 27 March 2022.
As of October 2026, at least 93.334 people have been detained under the state of exception.
GIPES and Amnesty International have pointed out that mass and arbitrary detentions, and possible crimes against humanity, have been committed under the state of exception.
President Nayib Bukele has said that there is a prisoner release plan that seeks to reduce the execution of prison sentences for persons convicted during the state of exception, or whom the government presumes to be guilty even though no judgment has yet been issued. Beyond the president’s statements at the press conferences of 13 and 16 October 2026, there is no clear information about the content and scope of the plan.
Under Salvadoran law, the legal pathways that may be activated to grant this type of benefit to persons sentenced to prison terms are:
Conditional release.
Early conditional release.
Controlled release.
Under Salvadoran law, the legal pathway that may be activated to grant sentence reductions to persons whose proceedings are active and who have not yet been convicted is the abbreviated procedure.
The abbreviated procedure requires the person to confess to having committed the offenses charged. The benefit they may receive is a sentence reduction of up to one-third of the minimum prison sentence provided for.
The systematic and widespread application of abbreviated procedures to those detained during the state of exception could have the following effects:
The confessions of the accused would be massively incorporated as evidence of the commission of the offenses attributed to them.
The clearing of the numerous criminal proceedings opened during the state of exception would be expedited.
The government narrative that all those detained during the state of exception were guilty would be reinforced.
The accused would be sentenced to lower prison terms than those they would have received without an abbreviated procedure.
For the abbreviated procedure to operate regularly, conditions must exist that guarantee that the confessions of the accused have been made without any coercion.
The Salvadoran criminal justice system does not provide conditions for the accused to give a confession free of any coercion, for the following reasons:
There is a risk of systematic and widespread torture and ill-treatment of persons in State custody.
There is a lack of separation of powers and, in particular, a lack of independence of the judiciary and the Attorney General’s Office.
The prohibition on compelling the accused to testify has been suspended under the state of exception.
An adequate solution for judicially resolving the tens of thousands of cases opened during the state of exception must guarantee punishment of the offenses committed and public security, weighing justice, truth, and the fundamental rights of the accused. A solution that considers these circumstances in an integrated way is the independent commission for the review of judicial cases proposed by GIPES (Ad Hoc Commission).
For an Ad Hoc Commission to operate, it is necessary for the Salvadoran State, and in particular the Executive Branch and the Attorney General’s Office, to accept it and to be willing to cooperate with it in a coordinated manner.
It is recommended that an Ad Hoc Commission meet the following characteristics:
Neither the appointment of the members of the Ad Hoc Commission nor its funding may depend on the Salvadoran State.
It must be established in advance which cases the commission will examine.
The commission must have unrestricted access to the judicial case files and to those of the Attorney General’s Office related to each case.
The commission must examine each case individually.
The analysis of each case must conclude with a report that assesses the evidence presented in the proceedings and, on that basis, formulates a recommendation on the action the Attorney General’s Office should take.
If it is concluded that the charges cannot be substantiated and there is no reasonable possibility of introducing new evidence, the commission may recommend that the Attorney General’s Office request definitive or provisional dismissal.
If the person has already been convicted by a final judgment and it is concluded that the conviction was based on false evidence, that a constitutional guarantee was directly and manifestly violated, or that there are new facts or evidence, the commission will recommend that the Attorney General’s Office file a motion for review.
The reports issued by the commission will also be delivered to the defense counsel or relatives of the convicted person, so that they may file any appeals or legal actions they consider appropriate on their own.
The commission may directly file habeas corpus petitions before the second-instance chambers or before the Constitutional Chamber of the Supreme Court of Justice.




Comments